Back to overview
Back to overview

A roofing choice: Shingles vs. metal roofing

When it comes to roofing, there are several options to choose from and the decision can be challenging. The two most popular options for contractors include shingles and metal roofing (trapezoidal sheet metal roofs).
26. June 2024
Comparison metal roof vs. asphalt shingles

Each has its own unique advantages and drawbacks, so it's important to understand the differences between them before deciding on which one is right for your project. Another consideration is if you have the right tools to ensure efficient and proper material installation. For example, the SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® Metal Roofing System, developed by BECK, is the ultimate installation tool when it comes to metal roofing. Since the SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fasteners are pneumatically driven in, metal roofing can be put in quickly and efficiently.

BUT WHICH ROOFING OPTION IS BEST FOR YOUR CLIENT? LET’S COMPARE THE TWO OPTIONS: Shingles vs. metal roofs!

A man puts asphalt shingles on a roof

shingles: the traditional choice

Asphalt shingle roofs remain one of the most popular choices when it comes to roofing. They come in several different shapes, colors, and sizes and can be installed relatively quickly. Asphalt shingle roofs are also an affordable material, making them a great option for those on a budget. On top of this, they hold up well against wind damage and hail damage, meaning they’ll last longer than some other types of roofs.

However, asphalt shingle roofs don't last forever—they typically last only about 15–20 years before needing to be replaced or repaired. Additionally, they require maintenance and repairs more often since they're prone to cracking and fading over time due to sun exposure (UV Rays). Because of this, asphalt shingle roofs require more frequent inspections than metal roofs do to ensure that everything is functioning properly. Lastly, asphalt shingles aren't always environmentally friendly because they contain petroleum products that can harm the planet if not disposed of properly.

metal roofing: the modern alternative 

Metal roofing has gained popularity recently due to its durability and longevity. Metal roofs can last up to 50 years or more, making them a more cost-effective option eventually.

LAYING TRAPEZOIDAL SHEET METAL: THE BEST ARGUMENTS FOR A METAL ROOF

Advantages of metal roofs

1

Trapezoidal sheet metal roofs can withstand extreme weather conditions such as strong winds, hail and snow.

2

Metal roofs are sustainable and eco-friendly, as they can be made from recycled materials and are 100% recyclable at the end of their life. This means that metal roofing does not contribute to landfill waste and helps to reduce the environmental impact of roofing materials.

3

Metal roofing can also help to reduce energy costs by reflecting sunlight and reducing heat absorption. This can help to keep the home cooler in the summer and reduce the need for air conditioning. Some types of metal roofing can even be installed over an existing roof, which can help to reduce waste and minimize the environmental impact of the installation process.

4

Some types of metal roofing can even be installed over an existing roof, which can help to reduce waste and minimize the environmental impact of the installation process.

5

Despite the higher initial investment compared to shingles, long-term savings outweigh the costs.

6

Although trapezoidal sheet metal roofs can cause noise when it rains, this can be mitigated with additional insulation or special materials.

Advantages of metal roofs

1

ROOF DECISION MADE EASY: SHINGLES VS. TRAPEZOIDAL SHEET METAL ROOFS INSTALLED WITH SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® NAIL SCREW fasteners

When deliberating between shingles and metal roofing, it's crucial to weigh the merits and drawbacks of each. Shingles offer a traditional and cost-effective solution, yet they may necessitate more frequent replacements and are susceptible to severe weather. On the other hand, metal roofing presents a contemporary and robust alternative, promising long-term savings despite potentially higher upfront expenses.

Roofloc® Scrail® metal roof systems

SCRAIL® ROOFLOC®: THE EFFICIENT CHOICE FOR THE INSTALLATION OF METAL ROOFS

Are you planning to install a metal roof? Then BECK's innovative SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fastening system is the perfect solution for faster, easier and more efficient installation. The special nail screw fasteners combine the strength of a screw with the speed of a nail and are up to 8 times faster than conventional screws, saving you up to 30% of installation time! Plus, the SCRAIL® nail screw fasteners are also easy to remove and adjust, making them ideal for repairs or modifications. 

Discover the SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® system

FASTENING METAL ROOF: HOW IT WORKS

With the SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fastening system, you can fasten trapezoidal sheet metal on roofs and façades quickly and efficiently. Here's how it works:

  • Prepare the pneumatic nailer and connect the compressed air
  • Place SCRAIL® ROOFLOC nail screw fasteners in the magazine
  • Position the trapezoidal sheet
  • Place the ROOFLOC® nailer and drive the special SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fasteners with leak-proof EPDM washer through the sheet metal into the wood at regular intervals

If something needs to be replaced or repaired on the roof, the SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fasteners can be unscrewed quickly and easily at any time.

This is how easy it is to fasten a trapezoidal sheet metal roof: The SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fastening system specially developed for the installation of trapezoidal sheet metal roofs in the video

Discover the advantages of SCRAIL® ROOFLOC® nail screw fasteners for trapezoidal sheet metal roofs and request a product test now!